Canon EOS 600D VS Nikon D5100; Which One is a Better Camera?

Both Canon EOS 600D and Nikon D5100 are targeted for keen amateur photographers as well as professionals as a back-up camera. We have lots of emails asking about the comparison review of these two popular DSLRs and which camera is a better camera. This post will compare both cameras and hopefully at the end of the article you have the idea on which camera will suit you best.

Canon EOS 600D Latest Price Info | Nikon D5100 Latest Price Info

Highlight EOS 600D & D5100

Canon EOS 600D

Viewfinder : Optical viewfinder has a 95 percent frame coverage with 0.85x magnification achieved.
LCD Monitor : Equipped with 3.1-inch LCD display which has a resolution up to 1,040,000 dots and can be rotated.
Image Stabilizer: Equipped with a lens that has a feature OIS (Optical Image Stabilizer).
Flash : Equipped with internal flash that has Guide Number Approx. 13/43 (at ISO 100 in meters/feet).
Lens : Equipped with new Canon EF-S 18-55mm IS II Lens kit.

Nikon D5100

Viewfinder : Viewfinder frame coverage up to 95 percent.
LCD Monitor : Equipped with 3-inch LCD display which has a resolution up to 921,000 dots and can be rotated.
Image Stabilizer: Equipped with a lens that offers Vibration Reduction (VR) feature.
Flash : Equipped with internal flash that has Guide Number Approx. 39/12, 43/13 (at ISO 100, 68°F/20°C ft/m).
Lens : Equipped with a Nikon 18-55mm AF-S DX VR lens kit.

Features & Operation

Canon EOS 600D

The Canon EOS 600D has a Scene Intelligent Auto Mode feature that allows users to use the optimal settings for recording videos automatically. While in Live View mode the camera is able to detect faces that become the object of your photo, and equipped with a creative filter that has a variety effects such as Fisheye and miniature that can be saved as new files.

Wireless Flash Control
The Canon EOS 600D works with nine AF points and iFCL metering system like those on the Canon EOS 60D with 63 focus points. In addition, the Canon EOS 600D can record JPEG and RAW data. While other features of interest is Wireless Flash Control which has functions to control the external flash from the camera.

The Canon EOS 600D uses Canon Lithium-ion battery LP-E8, which can produce 510 up to 1020 images. While in Live View mode, the battery is capable of producing 170 up to 360 images that has above average battery capacity of other entry-level SLR camera for photos and videos.

This camera has a DIGIC 4 processor with 14 bit that capable for improving the quality of camera speed to capture images and video. For example on the quality of JPEG and RAW, the camera capable to capture with speed of 3.66 frames per second.

The Canon 600D equipped with a video feature that offers quality Full HD resolution of 1,920 x 1,080 pixels which is better than the EOS 500D that has a video resolution of 720p. In addition you can record video files which can be recorded as H.264 MOV, so you can edit your videos with ease. This camera comes with offers many functions as a video camera SLR that lets you set the aperture as you want as well as other settings that can be controlled manually.

To save battery, you can add an optional Battery Grip BG-E8 on the Canon EOS 600D which will help conserve battery life when you record video in a long time. In addition you can also use the external flash Canon Speedlite 320EX and a remote control.

Nikon D5100

The Nikon D5100 is a digital SLR camera that can be used easily by beginners. The Beginners can use the automatic settings or with 16 scene modes options and setting manually. The camera is equipped with a Fn button which provides quick access to several functions including the HDR effect.

Feature Benefit
The Nikon D5100 has better features than the Canon EOS 600D, by optimizing the eleven areas of auto focus sensor which is equipped with a plus sign in the middle and have the option of WhiteBalance at Kelvin. In addition, the performance of D-Lighting feature has very well function with dynamic optimization.

This camera uses Nikon Battery EN-EL 14 that can capture images up to 690-1240 pictures when you are recording using the optical viewfinder. But if you use LiveView mode, battery capacity will drop drastically and has only capable of capturing images around 190-390 images. Thus, the battery is still good enough for the size of a DSLR though still below the canon.

In a test of speed, the Nikon D5100 is capable of recording approximately 3.88-3.94 images with RAW + JPEG files per second. While in Live View mode, this camera has auto focus which reacts faster than the Canon 600D. The Auto Focus of Nikon D5100 is able to react within about 1.82 seconds, while the Canon 600D is only able to react in time 3.81 seconds.

The Nikon D5100 besides having three frame rates (30, 25, and 24 fps), this camera also has HD resolution thath capable to recording video with a resolution (1.920×1.080 and 1280 X720 pixel). To compress the video, this camera uses Quicktime MOV feature on the camera while the Canon EOS 600D using H.264 Codec features. In addition, you can set the aperture and the volume manually on a Nikon D5100.

The Nikon D5100 allows users to use an external microphone ME-1 that has been integrated by the camera. But you will be a little disappointed with this camera because it does not have an external battery grip.

Picture Quality

Canon EOS 600D

The Canon EOS 600D has 1574 pairs of lines that are able to convince the camera to produce high image quality. The images sharpness at ISO 1600 experienced only a slight decrease of about 100 lp / Bh but still able to exceed the Canon EOS 60D on the same sensor resolution. While the dynamic-range at ISO 100 to ISO 800 is also quite impressive.

In comparison preview images on the monitor at ISO 1600 with magnification up to 100%, you will not see the noise produced by the EOS 600D. However, the image will lose contrast up to 26% at ISO 100.

You’ll start to see some noises when printing at A3 size at ISO 6400, the noise of this camera is quite disturbing the color on the subject and the camera produces a high enough noise that can not be avoided at ISO 12800. You will be quite disappointed when using the Maximum ISO that would lower the picture detail about 70%.

Nikon D5100

In laboratory testing, the Nikon D5100 image sharpness up to ISO 800 is comparable to the Nikon D7000. The Nikon D5100 has 1486 lines per picture height at ISO 100 while the D7000 has 1348 lines per picture height.

The Laboratory results are quite impressive and this camera produce images with lower noise compared to the Canon 600D. When printing your photos in A3 size at ISO 6400, you will be surprised to see that your photos still look great with lots of detail and acceptable noise.


Which One is a Better camera?

The Canon 600D offers excellent image sharpness quality and features a full HD video with manual mode. While Nikon D5100 offers quality, low noise in images with better speed and it also has a better battery performance. I’ve been a Canon user since the days of the EOS 300D, but if I have to sell all my photography gear and start it over, i would buy the Nikon D5100 over the EOS 600D in a heartbeat.

Leave a Reply